2nd XV - Report
| East Kilbride | 44 | vs | 8 | Greenock Wanderers |
2nds triumph in Promotion Play Off Final
EK's 2nd XV had an overwhelming victory in the Promotion Play Off Final today against Greenock Wanderers 2nds, 44-8. Man of the Match - Fraser Little. Hat trick hero - Gary Thornton
The result was never really in doubt after 8 minutes, when centre Gary Thornton ran 30 metres round and through the Greenock defence that simply did not want to tackle him. Bert Blackwood converted to make it 7-0.
It took another 10 minutes before EK scored again - they scorned a number of opportunities, but Bert kicked a penalty to make it 10-0.
The EK forwards were dominant, through good play and Greenock inefficiency - the first 3 Greenock line out throws were seriously squint, with EK stealing their other two line outs through good jumping.
The EK halfbacks - Little and Blackwood - were operating well and excellent kicking by the latter gave EK good position.
That said, Greenock kicked a penalty after 31 minutes to make it 10-3.
But this spurred EK in to action with another try by Thornton,converted by Bert. And they collected another penalty to make the score 18-3 at half time. There was only one team in it at that stage.
After only 4 minutes, a burst through midfield by Chris (Tophie) O'Neillllllll gave Alex Irvine an opportunity to beat his marker and score a try in the left corner. Bert converted for 25-3.
Craig Ferguson Senior (known as Cramps on the day) got the next score, with another excellent Blackwood conversion from the touchline. Score: 32-3.
It looked as if the nearest Greenock would get to scoring was when one of their players mistook the 5 metre line as the try line, but they kept plugging away, and finally scored a good unconverted try in the last minutes.
But before that, Gary Thornton completed his hat trick as Greenock again took evasive action to avoid bodily contact with him. Blackwood converted.
The final score camefrom a line out with Ferguson breaking through and the final pass gave club captain Scott Huge Johnston the opportunity to get on the scoresheet. As befitting his general kicking on the day, Huge missed the conversion by a wide margin despite being just in front of the posts but it mattered not a jot.
This was a fantastic performance by the 2nds, well deserved. They were superior in all departments. The foundation was laid in the forwards where everyone played their part. Chris O'Neillllllll was particularly effective.
The half backs both competed for the man of the match award, as did try scoring machine Gary Thornton. The winner was Fraser Little for his smart service and disruptive work around the fringes of the contact area.
This result will hopefully mean that EK 2nds play next year in West Regional Reserve League Division 1, where they will encounter a higher quality of rugby. They will welcome the challenge.
A key feature of the play off success was the strong spirit shown by the squad throughout the season. Assistant Manager Bruce Beggans deserves congratulations for much of this, as does club captain Scott Johnston. Let's build on it next year.
Comments (16)
Jo McIntyre - 1 year agoAbsolutely disgusting! Not only did you cheat your way to a win! You deprived your true 2nd team of going out and showing what they could do! Hope you feel as cheap ad you look! You have embarrassed the club and yourselves!
mark standlick - 1 year agoYou guys realise what we see when we click the named of these supposed 2s players right?
Ryan Kane - 1 year agoNot only have you put together quite a disrespectfull match report, but you have been so stupid as to link the profiles of your "2nd XV" team members, which actually lists them as "1st XV" players. If your going to cheat, be clever about it and cover it up well. It will be easy for the SRU officials to see this and the fact that I an RBS Rugby Force representative, this will definitely be reported. Fair game!
Steven Lannon - 1 year ago[Comment removed by Malcolm MacDonald]
Alasdair Blackwood - 1 year agoJo, Mike and Ryan, I am responding to your comments as a 2nd XV player and not on behalf of the club.
Below I have listed the 1st XV in their last league game of the season. The rules for the 2nd XV play-offs clearly state that no player starting in the previous 1st XV match can start for the 2nd XV in their next match. It does, however, state that 1st XV replacements can.
As you will see, the only players from the last 1st XV game to play on Saturday were Fraser Little, Gary Thornton and Euan Perry. All of which were replacements below.
As a 2nd XV player there would have been an outcry at EK if we had parachuted in 1st XV players to win us the play-offs. The 2nds had won all but one game until the play-offs and were determined to decide their own destiny.
The bigger picture is that all eight of the teams contesting the play-offs should be in their own league below West 1. The Pod system does not help player development as there are many teams who can barely raise teams on a Saturday.
Good luck next season.
15 Fraser Stott, 14 Ian Brown, 13 Scott Shankie, 12 Graeme Blackwood, 11 Kenny McDermott, 10 Robbie Greenfield, 9 Ian Stevenson, 8 Calum Aitken, 7 JB Timmons, 6 Gareth Jones, 5 Paul Rosie (Captain), 4. Craig Ferguson Junior, 3 Stephen Millar, 2 Rian Anderson, 1 Chris Mclellan. Replacements: Euan Perry, Gary Thornton, Fraser Little (all used)
craig ferguson - 1 year ago[Comment removed by Malcolm MacDonald]
Malcolm MacDonald - 1 year agoGreenock - apologies for the replies from 2 of our players, which I have deleted. Apologies also if u do not like my match report. I did get the impression no one wanted to go near Gary Thornton. I did not list our team in the match report as I was short of time but it was posted on weds or thurs before the match so nothing to hide in our team selection.
We are happy to explain our team section as required.
Steven Lannon - 1 year agoWhy was my comment deleted? It didnt break any rules. I dont take kindly to be being called a cheat, or cheap for that matter, hence my satirical reply.
I am fully entitled to my own opinion and the fact it has been deleted because you didnt like what i had to say is a little disappointing.
Stuart McT - 1 year agoGreenock, theres no point in leaving class-less comments. The better team won on the day. If there is any doubt about the validity of the team fielded, then I'm sure the proper officials will be notified and an investigation will be launched.
Alasdair, regarding your explanation; since you mentioned him - your scrum-half has played 12 first XV games and only 2 games for your second XV (both of which were play-off games), surely you can understand the frustration of a few people on our end? However, as I said - the best team on the field won. Congratulations and good luck next year.
craig ferguson - 1 year agoAs i said in my previous comments that were deleted are you telling me that your 8,centre and stand off were not first team ? And 1 player does not win a game !.
Malcolm MacDonald - 1 year agoGreenock - no need to reply to above query. One day some of our players might learn to win with grace.
I am on holiday at present so can't access the teamsheets I send the SRU weekly. I do however believe our scrum half, would not regard himself as a regular 1st xv player. He has been frustrated by selection & has only started one or two games for the 1s at 9. My own view is that he cd do a great job there for us but our selectiion panel don't seem to bother about my views!!
Sorry if u don't approve of our selections. I emailed our team to the 2nd xv league secretary on thurs morning. We still stand by them.
Dave Cowie - 1 year agoOr YOUR players could learn to take defeat with grace....
Benjamin Bunny - 1 year agoCome on guys this I redundant ...
Greenock were told that EK were playing with 9 first team players in their starting team, a fact that was confirmed by some (somewhat emmbaressed) EK fans and further confirmed on you website. You can understand how this until then, unbeaten team(I think), could feel a little hard done by.
However it's not breaking any rules... they used the means they had at their disposal. Maybe Greenock woulda played three quarters of their 1s if they wernt playing a home game.
Just leave it guys :)
Scott Johnston - 1 year agoYES, the website says I am a 1st team player, that must have been that 1 game down at Annan I had this season.
I am sure the SRU will look at the selection issue and see that there is no case to answer. We have followed the rules and won fairly. Just a shame that a few folk from Greenock can not see that.
Good luck next year gentleman
Jason Currie - 1 year agoThe comments above are quite correct, a number of those that appeared on Saturday have played rugby for the first fifteen. In fact from the squad of 22 I believe it was only the two that haven’t, which is a fantastic celebration for the depth that we have developed in the squad this year.
I am hoping that we can continue this through into next year which will allow us to further realise some of our intrinsic goals. Having worked with the guy’s trough this year and seeing the talent pool at our disposal I am more than confident that we be competitive in West Reserve One (which of course will demonstrate we have been rightly promoted)
.
There are positive signs that this conveyor belt will continue with the thriving work done in our Academy, underpinned qualitative coaching.
As I understand it Greenock will be going through a coaching transition next season, I am hoping that they can continue to develop their playing pool to support this ambition.
Of course much of the above commentary is written from bitterness and fuelled by ignorance. EK are a transparent, honest club a point no doubt validated if the SRU did investigate.
Ian Stevenson - 1 year agotoo many people with too many opinions at our club unfortunatley (mostly is unconstructive)
games done, lts look at building for next season???Post A Comment




Not Selected

Comment & Share