After taking a 2-0 lead after 47 mins EP were pegged back and taken into extra time by a resilient Loxwood team. Tom Lyne (pictured) headed the winner in the first half of extra time.
Asa Nicholson had given the home side the lead after 27 mins from a Ryan Quirke free kick. Two mins after the break Quirke found Tilley in space who rifled a shot into the corner of the net giving EP a comfortable lead.
Loxwood then scored twice to take the tie into extra time with Lynes goal on 97 mins sending EP into the next round.