Manager Paul Bonham made a number of changes after the defeat on Saturday. Ken Feyi replaced Elliot Amadieu at left back, Ben Stevens returned at centre back to partner Craig Carby. Harry Scott replaced Brian Haule who dropped to the bench.
United took the lead in the first half with a Jack Wood header from a corner. Harry Scott equalised on the stroke of half time with a perfect lob over the United keeper.
Two goals in the second half from substitute Ken Feyi sealed the three points and the bragging rights for the red side of Aylesbury.
Aylesbury FC 3 Aylesbury United 1 - Match Report