This season was most notable for Barwell reaching the 1st Round proper of the FA Cup where they went out at home to Welling United of Step 1 - a game where the highlights were shown on the BBC on Match of the Day. In the league, Barwell finished very well in 9th position.

2016/2017

Barwell finished 14th in the Northern Premier League.

2017/2018

Barwell finished 10th in the Northern Premier League. This was not a season with much to shout about in the cup competitions with exits from the FA Cup in the 2nd Qualifying Round at AFC Telford and in the FA Trophy at home in the same round to Mildenhall Town.

2018/2019...

Barwell were moved to the newly created Central Premier Division of the Southern League.
Jimmy Ginnelly left the post as Barwell manager to join Nuneaton Borough and his assistant, Guy Hadland, was put in caretaker charge. Over a busy Christmas period Guy did enough to secure the job on a full time basis. Barwell finished the season in 16th place and also managed to reach the FA Trophy 1st round proper, going out at Spennymoor Town.

2019/2020...

The season that never was! Guy Hadland continued as manager and was looking forward to his first full season as manager. Barwell were on a good run when the season was brought to an abrupt end due to the Covid-19 pandemic. Their final game was a 4-1 win away at Bromsgrove Sporting and this placed them 12th. Barwell made the final of the Leicestershire Challenge Cup but the final, against Anstey Nomads, was never played. Brady Hickey and Tolani Omotola finished as top scorers.

2020/2021...

Another season that ended early due to Covid-19. Only 10 games were possible in the league, FA Cup and FA Trophy before the effects of the pandemic were once again felt across the football world. During the winter months and into early 2021, Barwell FC put together a successful bid for grants to put in an artificial pitch. This funding, along with money raised from local people and the fabulous supporters, saw the work start on 19th July 2021. A new dawn was coming for Barwell FC and the village of Barwell.

2021/2022...

The first full season played after the pandemic and one that saw Barwell retain their Step 3 status with a memorable 2-0 win away at local rivals Nuneaton Borough. It was a very mixed season with some good results but a number of disappointing scorelines. Ben Stephens was a highlight of the year, ending the campaign as the league's highest goalscorer. Guy Hadland stepped down as manager at the end of the season and was replaced by Ian King.

2022/2023...

Ian King and his backroom staff did an incredible job in their first season in charge of Barwell, finishing 8th last season. The season was filled with many highlight moments, such as the 3-1 home wins over both local rivals Nuneaton Borough and Coalville Town. Brady Hickey finished as the clubs top scorer in all competitions.

2023/24

This campaign would be filled with many up and downs as is part and parcel of non-league football. The most notable change would be the departure of Ian King in February 2024 following a win away at Leiston. King would leave for rivals Coalville Town. He would be replaced by the returning Jimmy Ginnelly and assistant Guy Hadland, who were appointed on a temporary basis in March. They did a good enough job, securing a 14th placed finish, to earn themselves the permanent job ahead of the 2024/25 season.