Extracted from the match programme Ebbw Vale v Cardiff 2/10/21
BIG GAMES, BIG NAMES
Before one man picked the Welsh team the WRU appointed selectors to do the job, they were known as the Big Five although when Wales lost they were called something else. When a player was selected his club celebrated until the bar ran dry but an entire brewery was on the verge of running out in 1948 when ten Cardiff players were picked for the game against England at Twickenham.
In the backs were Bleddyn Williams, Prince of Centres and scrum-half Hadyn Tanner who when a schoolboy in 1935 played in the Swansea team that beat the All-Blacks. After the war he joined Cardiff and was a key figure in the record breaking 1947/8 season when they played 41 games, winning 39 including one over Australia, losing two, scoring 803 points and 98 tries conceding only ten. Bleddyn who three years earlier flew a glider over the Rhine under fire got 41 of them.
Clubs played each other twice and not until the Cup was introduced did some meet three times in a season. In February 1982 we played Cardiff twice in eight days at Ebbw Vale and the teams were almost unchanged for both games. Cardiff made one for the second, their captain John Scott was otherwise engaged in Paris playing for England but as our programme editor noted “Such is Cardiff’s strength in depth he will hardly be missed!”
Both full-backs Paul ‘Pablo’ Rees and Wayne Bow were once clubmates, the Cardiff half-backs were Gareth Davies and Terry Holmes and the hookers were Alan Phillips already capped 15 times and a future international Ian Watkins who had just been selected for the Welsh Youth squad. Cardiff won both games, the Cup and Championship in which we came 12th. We had some consolation, an end of season tour to Canada and a double over Newport.
High scoring games between evenly matched sides is rugby at its best and there was one at the Arms Park in April 2000 that was a gem. Ebbw Vale and Cardiff were in form and half the players were, or soon would be, internationals and not only for Wales. In the Ebbw Vale lineup were Josh Taumalolo and Kuli Faletau of Tonga and Guy Easterby of Ireland. Cardiff won a memorable game 48-34, Neil Jenkins kicking 18 points, par for the course for the first player to score a thousand points in international matches.
In 1999/2000 we played in Scotland, Ireland, Romania and France where we won 21-19 at Toulon home of the French fleet and then sank them at Ebbw Vale by an incredible 56-26. Jason Strange kicked 12 goals in 13 attempts watched by Welsh coach Graham Henry who eight months before was at Wembley when his team beat England 32-31, a rare win over them who beat us in the previous five games and the following seven!
REL
Extracted from the programme for Ebbw Vale v Pontypridd September 25th 2021
THE 2006/07 PREMIERSHIP – A THRILLER TO THE VERY END
On March 8th 1986 we defeated Pontypridd 18-13 at home which brought us a rare double and the headline in the programme read “The Green, Green Grass Of Home – At Last.” It was our first match at home since January 15th after which wintry weather caused the postponement of games throughout the land. The resumption of fixtures after a long break and with Ponty our first visitors was welcomed by players and supporters as it will be this afternoon.
There were no weather problems in the successful 2006/07 season which sadly was Alex Codling’s last with us. We won 17, drew 3 and lost eight League and Cup games but it was two of the defeats that many remember most. In the first at Sardis Road on March 3rd we led in the closing stages but when referee Nigel Whitehouse blew up for time we had lost 22-31. The second game was at home to a Cardiff side featuring Andy Powell of the Blues who had a considerable influence on a game we lost 22-27. Disappointing but a losing bonus point was useful as the season’s climax approached.
There had never been such a close Premiership final with Neath going for a third successive title which they got with a 20-18 win at Sardis Road seven days before the season ended. A result that virtually ended Newport’s challenge because they had to beat Pontypridd at Rodney Parade AND score fifteen tries, in fact our Valley chums Ponty won 28-25.
Meanwhile we were finishing in style at ECP before the biggest crowd of a well supported season. With Alex Codling determined to leave us with a win and lock Neil Edwards celebrating his 150th appearance, we gained the runners-up spot beating a lively Llanelli 19-12. When the Newport-Ponty result was known the party started.
The crowd celebrated not just a vital win but for the whole season which the media considered was one of the best the Premiership had produced. As for the Steelmen a press comment on the final game hit the right note, “The squad proudly saluted their fans among scenes that had not been seen since the vanquishing of Toulouse in the Heineken Cup.” The top four placings were:-
P W D L For Agst Pts
1. Neath 26 17 2 7 704 473 53
2. Ebbw Vale 26 16 3 7 557 503 51
3.Newport 26 16 2 8 619 480 50
4.Pontypridd 26 16 1 9 543 504 49
REL
DERBY DAY AT THE HEAD OF THE VALLEYS
Our four pre-season games were well chosen and of great value to players and coaches. The last against a lively, skilful Cardiff Met side that lived up to its reputation drew the biggest crowd for a long time. They contributed to the Hospice of the Valleys and were rewarded with a good game as well as an exhibition by the juniors, Steelmen of the future.
It was the dress rehearsal of the opening of a new competition, the Indigo Cup and our first game in it is at Merthyr who we last played at ECP in January 2020 and therein lies several stories. It was a closer game than many expected, Merthyr won 19-17 and opened the scoring with a drop goal by Rhys Jones who a fortnight later rejoined us and was in the side that beat RGC 1404, the last game before rugby and civilisation as we knew it closed down in March 2020.
The game with Merthyr in January 2020 was televised and very close. One move lifted hopes for Ebbw Valians when our skipper Ashley Sweet seemed to have scored a try but it was disallowed by the referee because the Merthyr scrum-half had collided with him in the build-up. Ashley was coming to the end of an outstanding career with Ebbw Vale and it would have been a great finale for him.
Our team that day was Dan Haymond; Paul King, Aneurin Owen, Dom Franchi, Ewan Rosser; Lewis Williams, Matthew Flanagan; Ross Jones, Mikhail Blake, Robert Sevenoaks; Max Ayling, Ashley Sweet (capt.); Dan Hill, Dawid Rubasniak, Lewis Young.
Many are still with us, others will wear the red, white and green for the first time in a competitive match but all are rarin’ to go.
REL
THE FOURTH FRIENDLY – AND IT’S AT HOME!
Completing our pre-season friendlies with a game against Cardiff Met, and at home, is a grand idea and one to be enjoyed by watchers and valuable to the coach and his merry band. It will bring back memories of Cardiff College of Education, South Glamorgan Institute and UWIC, regular fixtures we enjoyed and generally won but only after a struggle for the students were always fit, fast and skilful and so are their successors Cardiff Met who do well in the Championship and British University rugby.
Cyncoed’s contribution to Welsh rugby is awesome, its Hall of Fame includes a string of Wales internationals among them Gareth Edwards who played for Cardiff College of Education against us in December 1966 (we won 11-0) and was capped four months later. Now the Met can add a Polish international, Dawid Rubasnaik, who began his rugby career at the Ebbw Fawr Learning Community, became a Steelman and has a special interest in Wednesday’s game against his Alma Mater.
The first of four league games we played against Cardiff Met was on October 13th 2012 when we were lording the Championship and were expected to register a comfortable win at Cyncoed. We did win but not comfortably for with the referee looking at his watch and our supporters looking for the exit the scores were level at 9-9. But cometh the moment, cometh an Irishman in the person of full-back Charlie Simpson. He dropped a goal, we won 12-9 and our 100% record in the Championship was kept. But not for long, a week later we lost at Whitland 29-30, our only league defeat that season.
The immediate challenge is the Indigo Premiership Cup, a competition devised by the WRU Community Rugby Director, Geraint John, once an outside-half and coach at Llanelli and Cardiff who played for South Glamorgan Institute at Ebbw Vale in October 1983 a game we won 18-14.
Our last home game was on March 7th 2020 when we beat RGC 1404 by 20 points to 17. Pre-season games this year have been of great value to coaches and players and so will be the fourth on Wednesday 8th September, it’s the final rehearsal – and it’s at home!
REL
WE’RE OFF TO SEE THE WIZARDS
A pre-season fixture with another Premiership team is unusual but as we are in a different pool to Aberavon in the Indigo Cup a match with them is welcome. Our clubs have produced memorable and exciting games and never was the well worn phrase “a game of two halves” more appropriate than on Friday evening 5th September 2019 when BBC Wales TV brought miles of cable, massive trucks, tons of technology and the inimitable Phil Steele to our ground. They hoped for some drama, excitement, thrills and spills and they got it.
Aberavon made themselves at home and led 17-0 at half-time, the alarm bells rang and Steelmen supporters viewed the immediate future with alarm. But like Hitchcock thrillers there was a tense finale and we won 19-17, the perfect beginning of a new season for Ebbw who won the first seven games and laid the foundation of a campaign of 20 wins, one draw (at Aberavon) and nine defeats, a 68% return. Another close run game came later in the season when we lost 10-9 to Merthyr in the Cup semi-final.
The game has changed beyond recognition since Alan Martin and Billy Mainwaring were Aberavon’s second row and Billy’s mother Evelyn watched closely in the stand. The Wizard’s historian Howard Evans describes her as “the best known club rugby supporter in Wales……she was often worth a few points to the Wizards.” Had there been TMOs in her day a decision against the Wizards would not have been accepted by a lady who was the perfect example of devotion to a club.
Ebbw Vale supporters are worth more than a ‘few’ points to the Steelmen and will make their presence felt at Aberavon after the disappointment of spending Saturday afternoon on the M4. They were missed at Maidenhead where a bigger London Scottish team mainly fully professional won by seven points. A proud Gregg Woods said, “To come up against a quality side like London Scottish and compete for 80 minutes was fantastic.”
The game was described in London Scottish sources as great, thrilling and a ‘cracker’ with Ebbw rising to an occasion many had not experienced before, among them Lewis Bates, Adam Williams, Connor Chapman son of a former Vale scrum-half Matthew and Joe Westwood grandson of one our greatest three-quarters, Keith.
There are many memories of games at the Talbot Athletic Ground one in particular. In September 2007 we kicked off early won 22-17, scored three tries to one and then dashed home to watch Wales beat Fiji in the World Cup in Nantes. That was the plan but Fiji won 38-34, their winning try was awarded by the TMO and they got through to the last eight and Wales went home.
REL
VALE v LONDON SCOTTISH AGAIN – AFTER A 60 YEAR GAP!
On Saturday we play a Scottish club of great repute. London Scottish were formed in 1878 and for almost a hundred years only Scotsmen could play for them a tradition that ended in 1996 when they went ‘open’ as London Irish and London Welsh had done. Twenty-five years later a South African played for Scotland and the Lions against his own country! At the Maidenhead RFC ground we will play London Scottish for only the second time, the first game with them was at home sixty years ago and we won 20-0.
1960/61 was a good season for Ebbw Vale even though we only finished fourth in the Welsh Championship. At half-back we had Wilf Hunt and Roy Evans, David Nash was the best No. 8 in Wales and wing Mel Williams was singled out by the press as a match winner. He was also a character, at Plymouth Albion on a bitterly cold afternoon in 1962 he joined the scrum to keep warm!
The Welsh Counties Championship final in 1961 was played at what we then called the Welfare Ground and there were five Ebbw Vale players in the Monmouthshire side that beat Glamorgan watched by the Big Five, the Welsh selectors. Youth rugby was flourishing and the Welsh lads shone brightly, especially an outside-half from Cwmcelyn Youth, David Watkins.
In 60/61 London Scottish played all the leading clubs in England and won the Middlesex Sevens. Several played for Scotland, two against Wales who lost at Murrayfield 3-0, their try scored by a wing listed in the programme as A R Smith (Ebbw Vale & Edinburgh Wanderers). Ebbw Valians among the mass of Welsh supporters at Murrayfield that afternoon were not surprised, they had seen the Flying Scotsman winning matches many times in a red, white and green jersey.
REL
FIXTURES PRESENT AND PAST (14/08/21)
On the last Saturday of June 2021 we played our first game since the first Saturday in March 2020. After months of watching rugby on the box, some exciting, some forgettable and none as good as watching a game live, we sighed with relief when the news from Westgate Street was good news. We will play in the Indigo Cup, a Premiership competition that divides east and west clubs all but one within a short journey of each other.
Parc y Pugh in Brecon was the perfect venue to play the first of three pre-season friendlies. Brecon needed a game before their WRU Plate commitments and as coach Gregg Woods said “We were looking for a run out before travelling to Richmond to play formidable London Scottish. It was the perfect fixture for us, a lovely ground and quite close for our supporters, you can train as much as you want but nothing beats actual game time.”
Eleven players made their Ebbw Vale debut, four of them played their first senior game and Gregg Woods told Brecon’s new coach, Matthew Lewis a former Steelman, he would like a return next summer and so say all of us.
Friendlies in August began in 2009 at Brynmawr when our former coach Alex Codling brought Barking and won 20-5. Bonymaen were narrowly beaten 10-3, we lost 23-27 at Glamorgan Wanderers and the writing was on the wall but at Sixways we almost beat a Worcester side who pipped us 21-20. Three August friendlies lost out of four heralded a season that ended in relegation.
Since then August games brought encouraging results like 2015 when we played well but lost 31-49 at Moseley, won 33-0 at Pontypool 33-0 and lost 7-22 home to London Welsh. There were two after-season games in May 2016 at Llandovery and Pontypridd, a semi-final and a final in the play-offs which ended in our favour.
Whatever the 2021/22 season brings we still need friendlies and this year we have three that will wet the appetite. Two are away and the third is at home to the Championship side Cardiff Met, once known as Cardiff Training College, South Glamorgan Institute and UWIC and as full of talent as they were.
Fixtures we once took for granted are now precious and the sad passing of Mike Treanor who as a player and administrator served the club so well was a reminder of the fixtures in pre-League days. In the 1970/71 season he was Club Secretary and Allan Foster was Fixture Secretary. They produced a fixture list of fifty-two matches, 39 against Welsh sides, 12 against English and one from Ireland, Bective Rangers who played in our colours, fielded Irish internationals, lost the game 37-0 but won the party after it.
REL
BACK TO THE BEACONS (28/07/21)
An away game at Brecon is overdue if only to visit a County that gave us some of our finest players. It’s been a long time since we returned to the Beacons to play one of the founder clubs of the Welsh Rugby Union and our first game in Powys since August 2012. We were in the Championship and played a pre-season friendly at Gwernyfed where former Steelmen, Robert Stephens, Chay Billen, Des Parry, Alun Phillips and others were coaching, coaxing and continuing their rugby lives. We won, enjoyed the afternoon and went on to win the Championship in which we only lost once.
A Cup tie still remembered took us over the moors in February 2000 to play Builth Wells and we had a strong squad including internationals past, present and future. Our side that pleasant day was Josh Taumalolo; Rhys Shorney, Jonathan Williams, Gareth Williams, Alan Harries; Jason Strange, Guy Easterby; Alun Phillips, Andrew Peacock, Andrew Metcalf; Glyn Llewellyn, Deiniol Jones; Nathan Budgett, Gareth Green, Paul Williams.
On the formidable bench were club captain Mark Jones, Noel Thomas, Lee Banks, Richard Smith, Shaun Connor, Stephen John. The referee was the best of his time, Derek Bevan and in the home side was prop Jeremy Pugh. We went on to beat Bonymaen at our ground which took us to a semi-final at Cardiff. We lost to regular Cup winners Llanelli 26-38 after a hesitant start but a resounding second half.
Our last game at Brecon was on the 17th of September 1979, a few weeks into our Centenary when we won a close game 12-10. Our coach Arthur Lewis spotted a centre in the home side and invited him to play for us at Arthur’s home club, Crumlin who were also celebrating a centenary. He was Des Parry who joined the Steelmen with so many from Breconshire among them Rob Stephens, Brian Thomas, Chay Billen, Alun Phillips, Kim Norkett and others who brightened our club on and off the field.
That’s the past. On Saturday a new era starts and where better than the Brecon Beacons National Park to be playing, watching, meeting old friends and making new ones. Enjoy.
FRANCE v WALES – A TALE OF TWO WINGS (16/03/21)
My first sight of a French team of any kind was at the Arms Park in March 1950, a sad occasion because two weeks before a ‘plane carrying Welsh supporters returning from Ireland crashed on landing at Llandow. There were only three survivors and in memory of the eighty who died buglers played Last Post before the kick-off. Wales won the game 21-0 and the Grand Slam for the first time since 1911 but the disaster cast a shadow over everything.
In the French side was 6’2” wing Michael Pomathious the first Frenchman to be selected bythe Barbarians which was a great honour in those days. In March 1952 Wales clinched another Grand Slam when they beat France 9-5 at St.Helen’s and Pomathious scored his side’s try. His opposite number Horace Phillips was playing on his home pitch and forty years later he and the Frenchman were re-united at St. Helen’s where in 1948 France won and Pomathious was chaired off by Welsh supporters!
He played for Agen who we met in the 2001/02 European Shield losing in France but hitting the headlines with a 59-10 victory at home in unusual circumstances. Supporters enjoyed it but were puzzled until it was disclosed that Agen had deliberately lost the game as they didn’t want to qualify for the semi-finals because of a fixture back-log. They were given a one-year ban from European competitions and fined a lot of euros which had just been introduced, £60,000 in ourmoney.
Another great French wing Emile N’Tamackscored 26 tries in 46 games for France and was in the Toulouse team that came to Ebbw Vale in the 1998/9 European Cup as firm favourites after imposing a cricket score on us in the first encounter. We rose to the occasion and Jason Strange’s conversion of a penalty try and four penalty goals gave us a 19-11 victory. But the story doesn’t end there and is so startling it’s best to quote from the Rugby Annual of Wales.
“Unpleasant scenes followed. Referee Ed Murray who had sent off Toulouse prop Cyril Vancheri for kicking (banned for 28 days), was jostled by French players. A touch judge also appeared to be pushed, as were police officers as they stepped in to protect the match officials. One policeman had his helmet knocked off. In the club house there were further incidents and the visitors left without attending the after match function.” Toulouse’sdefeat meant they played Ulster in Belfast not the south of France in the next round and someone in Ulster, who went on to win the European Cup,sent us a Thank You card.
The following season we got the double over Toulon and there was peace all round but the Toulouse game was recalled in the programme which is worth repeating. “Emile N’Tamack of Toulouse went on as a replacement at Ebbw Vale and had a try disallowed which added to the visitor’s anger but those present will remember him signing autographs and shrugging off any discussion on the disturbances.” Wing three-quarters were, and still are, the gentlemen of rugby football. Most of them anyway.
Since April 2020 we have passed the time recalling players and games in Ebbw Vale’s past with the encouragement and practical help of former players, club officers and rugby historians. This is the last in the series and is written in the hope that the future will be as interesting and as enjoyable as the past was.
ITALIA v CYMRU – RYGBI YN ROMA (06/03/21)
The 2021 Six Nations tournament has produced exciting finishes, too much controversy and a Triple Crown for Wales with a Grand Slam to play for. Among the newcomers who have done so well are two with Ebbw Vale links. Louis Rees Zammit is the nephew of Paul ‘Pablo’ Rees our dashing full-back of four decades ago and Callum Sheedy is the nephew of our brilliant outside-half Mike Boys who out-witted every opposition and was the key player in 1994/5 when we were promoted.
In the last Rugby World Cup our favourite other team was Japan, in the Six Nations it’s Italy. Their anthem is operatic, sung with passion and pride and to hear it on home ground must be worth the journey alone. Supporters of the Home Unions now enjoy Rome in the Spring as much, if not more, than April in Paris, it’s a major sporting occasion in a football country where rugby is increasingly popular with clubs playing in the Pro 14 and European Cup.
Like all South Wales valley towns we have strong links with everything Italian, strengthened by Clive Burgess when he moved to Lombardy to work in a vineyard and play for Brescia. In 1983 Ebbw Vale went there on a hectic three match tour and rested between games at Lake Garda. Rugby in paradise.
Among the many Italian families who emigrated to South Wales were the Sidolis whose ice cream factory in Market Square, Ebbw Vale is renowned. It’s not far from our ground where in March 2003 two Sidoli brothers from another branch of the family were on opposite sides, Robert for Pontypridd and Peter for Ebbw Vale. Peter’s team won.
In 2003 Robert Sidoli played his sixth game for Wales in the land of his fathers expecting to win in Rome’s Olympic Stadium but the Azzurri had a player of world class quality, an outside-half who played for Stade Francais. Diego Dominguez converted Italy’s three tries and kicked a penalty and dropped two goals in a historic 30-22 win.
The last time an Italian team played at Ebbw Vale was in October 2001, a European Shield tie against Rovigo, a lively club from a lovely town where rugby is popular. On a frost-bitten pitch they were not accustomed to Rovigo were formidable opponents but we won a tense encounter 28-26 through tries by Andrew Wagstaff and Matthew Jones, both converted by Gareth Cull who added four penalty goals.
Our coaches that season were Mike Ruddock and Kevin Hopkins and the club captain was Chay Billen, who did not play against Rovigo. The Ebbw Vale team that did will bring back memories to many – Matthew James; Gareth Cull, Rhys Shorney, David Weatherly (capt.), Andrew Wagstaff; Scott Mitchell, Gareth Betts; Iestyn Thomas, Jonathan Evans, Martin Jones; Ockert Boyse, Neil Edwards; Kati Tuipuloto, Paul Williams, Will Thomas. Replacements, Damien Penisini, Leyton Phillips, Rhys Williams, Gavin Evans, Kevin Ellis, Paul Matthews, Ross Watts.
Undefeated Wales will be firm favourites when they return to the Stadio Oiympico for the fourth round of this year’s Six Nations, a game of added interest to Ebbw Valians who will pay special attention to the nephews of two of their all-time favourites, Pablo and Boysie.
WALES v ENGLAND 1963 – DENZIL’S DEBUT
Wales v England is still a Derby game but not as much as it was when Welsh clubs regularly played mini internationals against their English equivalents. When Denzil Williams made his Welsh debut in January 1963 it was against an England XV composed of players from twelve clubs, Oxford and Cambridge Universities, Coventry, Fylde, Durham City, Sale, Wasps, Rosslyn Park, Bristol, Torquay Athletic, Exeter and Bedford.
Wales selected six new caps, Denzil Williams (Ebbw Vale), David Watkins (Newport), the captain Clive Rowlands (Pontypool), Brian Thomas (Neath), Robert Michaelson (Aberavon) and Dai Hayward (Cardiff). England won 13-6 with two of their all-time greats prominent, outside-half Richard Sharpe and wing Peter Jackson. It was a rare win at the Arms Park for them but Ebbw Valians were pleased to read in one report that “big Ebbw Vale lock Denzil Williams would become a good international prop.”
It was the start of an outstanding international career for the lad from Trefil, thirty-six games against each of the top nations in a period when Wales played forty-three. A Lion in New Zealand and Australia in 1966, Denzil returned with Wales in 1969 and played in each of the seven games of a tour that ended in Fiji when caps were not awarded but a long term friendship with rugby in the South Seas began.
Wales defeated Otago, Wellington, Australia and Fiji, drew with Taranaki and lost both Tests in New Zealand which was customary at the time and still is. The referees were local and the need for neutral officials was emphasised in the second Test in Auckland when the New Zealand referee Pat Murphy “leapt with joy when the Kiwi full back dropped a goal from 55 yards!”
Denzil’s record as an international player in non-professional times is impressive. He played nine games against England and was on the winning side six times, two were drawn, only one was lost and that was his debut game in 1963. There were fewer international games then but Denzil played three times against the All-Blacks and twice against South Africa and Australia. Add the Barbarians, Monmouthshire and every top club in Britain and Ireland and you get a much travelled, very experienced top notch rugby football international.
The road to the top began with club rugby with the occasional County game and WRU trial matches. In 1962/3 there were two, the first in Ebbw Vale when our hooker Martin Preece in the Possibles faced Llanelli’s Norman Gale. Denzil Williams was in the final trial at Newport, and so was his clubmate back row forward Graham jones who joined Denzil in the Welsh team in 1963 against Scotland, Ireland and France.
The making of an international player was the duty of clubs with top class fixtures. When Bath played at Ebbw Vale we witnessed the 1st XV debut of Jeremy Guscott, when Coventry came they brought David Duckham and our annual fixture with Gloucester was England v Wales in miniature. It was from those games that Denzil and many like him gained the experience to qualify for country and the Lions. Now of the Home Countries only England has clubs that are stepping stones to the national team.
The third round of the 2021 Six Nations brings together neighbours with a history stretching back to their first encounter in 1881. We have played each other 136 times, England winning 63, Wales 59 with 12 drawn, and this year’s encounter is expected to be tense and tough but hopefully the red cards will stay in the referee’s pockets, if only to avoid post-match inquests on their validity.
SCOTLAND v WALES – WEARY WEEK-ENDS AND NO WINS
The biennial outing to Murrayfield in February was once the most popular away fixture of them all. By bus and by train in enthusiastic mood we crossed two borders and headed for Edinburgh even though fog, frost and failure often awaited us. I took the high road in 1957, 1959 and 1961 but felt low coming back because Wales lost each time so I didn’t go again. The journey was not a comfortable one, it began at Beaufort LMS station on Friday evening and when dawn broke we were in Princes Street with a long day and night ahead of us.
Scotland won the three games I saw, 9-6, 6-5 and 3-0 with only five tries overall one of them by a wing, a Cambridge Blue and a Masters of Mathematics who was a master of change of pace and captain of his country, including a game in 1960 at Cardiff when he was listed as Arthur Smith (Ebbw Vale).
In 1962 a few months before he captained the Lions in South Africa, Arthur led a Scottish team with a full-back named Scotland and a flanker named Glasgow. They won in Wales for the first time in 25 years and their first at the Arms Park in thirty-five. The evening before Ebbw Vale had new visitors, the oldest Scottish club Edinburgh Academicals who won 6-3. Both games were played in unpleasant conditions but two wins in Wales over one week-end was ample compensation for the visitors.
Our main links with Scottish teams were with Gala but we also played Watsonians on their Christmas tours. In 1979 a short New Zealand tour in England and Scotland included a game in Dundee against the Anglo-Scots whose lock was J A Stewart (Watsonians and Ebbw Vale). Can anyone remember him?
Smith is the most common name in Scotland and there are three wings of that clan who stand out. Arthur of course is one and before his time there was Ian who created history in the 1925 Five Nations when in an all-Oxford University three-quarter line he scored four tries against France and another four against Wales.
The third, George Smith, played for the 1950 Lions in Australia and New Zealand and returned as their manager on the historic 1971 tour. In February 1949 at Murrayfield he scored a try in Scotland’s 6-5 win over Wales, a controversial match because captaining the Scots was forward Doug Keller who two seasons before had played for Australia against them.
In 1950 Wales won the Grand Slam for the first time since 1911 and began 1951 with a comfortable 23-5 win over England at Swansea making them firm favourites to devour Scotland two weeks later. It was not to be, the game is remembered as the Murrayfield Massacre with the Scots up-ending a much fancied Wales 19-0. The turning point was a drop goal from the touchline by Scottish skipper and No. 8 Peter Kininmonth which might have been unintentional but it counted. Not many No 8s have dropped goals, probably the last was Emyr Lewis who won the 1993 Cup Final that way. Has an Ebbw Vale No 8 ever dropped a goal? Someone like Dai Fryer perhaps.
We don’t want a drama of that kind when we play at Murrayfield in the second round of this year’s Six Nations, a simple win will do nicely on a ground where Wales have won six, lost four and drawn one of our last ten games there. Let’s hope daffodils not the flowers of the forest will take first prize at this year’s Murrayfield Show.
WALES v IRELAND – ST HELEN’S 1949
In post-Second World War years big crowds of genuine rugby enthusiasts watched club rugby and hoped, some probably prayed, they would get a ticket for an international match. In March 1949 there were 40,000 lucky ones at St. Helen’s when Wales played Ireland and while they didn’t see a classic they had plenty to talk about when the referee Tom Pearce blew the final whistle. Two months later he returned to Wales and scored 92 for Essex when they played Glamorgan at Ebbw Vale. How times have changed!
Wales wore white shorts for the first time, “for reasons connected with dyeing and laundering rather than taste or high policy” but it didn’t help because with Jackie Kyle a genius at outside-half Ireland won the game 5-0 and with it the Championship and Triple Crown. Kyle’s breakaway on the blind side and his punt ahead was followed up by open-side wing-forward Joe McCarthy of the Dolphin club. And like a dolphin he leapt over the Welsh line, caught the ball in mid-air and scored a try. But was he offside?
The try at the Mumbles End was converted by full-back George Norton of Bective Rangers a side we got to know very well. He was the only member of his club in the 1949 Irish team, a Lone Ranger one might say, and a few months later went with the 1950 Lions to Australia and New Zealand. He didn’t complete the tour through injury and Wales’s Golden Boy Lewis Jones became the first ever Lions replacement. We played Bective Rangers eight times in the 50s and 60s on the eve or the day after a Wales – Ireland game winning four, drawing one and losing three. Our colours were similar but theirs were officially rose, not red, white and green.
Five Nations fixtures were the same every season, Wales played England in January, Scotland in February and Ireland and France in March a busy month that included celebrations of St. David and St. Patrick who some believe was Welsh. If so Ireland have a Patron Saint who’s not Irish but what’s in a name? We have a devoted member who’s a Patrick but he’s a David at heart.
Tries were rare in the old days but three Ebbw Vale players got one for Wales against Ireland, wing forward Graham Jones (1963), Denzil Williams (1969) and Clive Burgess on his Welsh debut in 1977 while Paul Ringer then a Scarlet who won his first cap from Ebbw Vale scored a try against the Irish in 1979.
In the Wales v Ireland game at Swansea in 1949 only one try was scored which was not unusual in those days. Seventy one years later in an Autumn Nations Cup game Ireland beat Wales 32-9 in Dublin but despite the scoreline only two tries were scored which was as disappointing as the game itself. Hopefully the next Wales v Ireland encounter will be a spectacle with more than two tries, and with a different result!
A GRAND SLAM AND THE LIONS ROAR
1971 was a great year for British and Irish rugby, especially for the Welsh who saw their team win a Grand Slam for the first time in nineteen years using only sixteen players. As a result twelve of the side were selected for the Lions party to tour Australia and New Zealand and the captain and coach were both Welsh.
Ebbw Valians particularly enjoyed the 1971 Five Nations because Arthur Lewis and Denzil Williams were in the Welsh team. Arthur missed the Scottish game through injury and was temporarily replaced by Ian Hall of Aberavon but he returned for the Triple Crown decider against Ireland when Denzil played his 35th game for Wales creating a new record for a forward.
In its 50th anniversary we should recall a great Welsh team that played in such an adventurous way – J P R Williams, Gerald Davies, John Dawes (captain), Mike Roberts, Mervyn Davies and John Taylor of London Welsh, John Bevan, Barry John and Gareth Edwards of Cardiff, Barrie Llewellyn and Delme Thomas of Llanelli, Denzil Williams and Arthur Lewis of Ebbw Vale, Jeff Young of Harrogate and Dai Morris of Neath. A galaxy of stars that has never been out-shone.
The opening game against England was the first at the newly named National Stadium and was won comfortably 22-6. Murrayfield as usual was a tough place for Wales but in a thriller we won 19-18 through a late try by Gerald Davies converted from the touchline by wing-forward John Taylor. The move began at a lineout won by experienced warriors Delme Thomas and Denzil Williams, unsung heroes of an historic victory.
The 23-9 win over Ireland in Cardiff clinched the Triple Crown and what followed was a Grand Slam thriller at Stade Colombes where Wales hadn’t won for 14 years. The decisive try was inspired by J P R Williams who in his own 25 turned defence into attack, ran 70 yards before feeding Gareth Edwards who scored. Most of the record crowd of 60,000 were silent but those wearing red scarves, berets and rosettes were not. It was a great week-end, the entente was very cordiale and they even based a film on it.
John Dawes unsurprisingly was made captain of the 1971 Lions, former Scottish wing Doug Smith was manager and his “assistant” alias the coach was Carwyn James. The task before them was immense, and our interest in the tour was magnified by the inclusion of Arthur Lewis.
After a stop in Hong Kong the Lions landed in Brisbane and two days later with jet lag affecting them they played Queensland and lost 15-11. They soon recovered, beat Australia and began the main tour in New Zealand who were firm favourites but as one home reporter declared “the Lions roared loudest” and played crowd pleasing rugby which opened many eyes Down Under and influenced the way rugby was played there.
Every game in New Zealand was intense but one at Christchurch went too far and was described as brutal and vicious. Two key Lions front-row forwards Sandy Carmichael and Ray McLoughlin were so severely punched they could not play again and replacements were flown out. In the middle of the Battle of Canterbury was the powerful Arthur Lewis who scored a try, John Bevan scoring the other in a game won by the Lions 14-3 but remembered for the wrong reason.
The 1971 Lions are still the only side to win a series in New Zealand and the coaching and player-management brilliance of Carwyn James was widely recognised but a coach like a prophet is never honoured in his own land. He should have been chosen as the Welsh national team coach, after all he was, and still is, the only man to coach three teams, the Lions, Llanelli and the Barbarians, that defeated New Zealand. What more could be asked of a coach.
POSTCRIPT. In a recent article the date of our first game with Aberavon was given as Christmas Day 1922. We did play them on that date but Howard Evans, rugby historian and statistician who has written the history of the Wizards, says that the first Ebbw Vale v Aberavon game was played on December 29th 1894. Which poses a question, how did we get to Port Talbot a hundred plus years ago?
2016 – A HAPPY NEW YEAR
“White Christmas” sold millions of records and was written by Irving Berlin whose childhood was in Russia before his parents emigrated to America. He couldn’t have dreamed of a white Christmas like the ones he used to know and I dreaded them because snow covered pitches and icy surfaces cancelled matches, as it did with a vengeance in the 2009/10 season.
After losing 14-9 at Pontypool on December 5th we were inactive until January 26th when we should have been home to Llanelli in the Cup. Our ground was frozen, surprisingly Tredegar’s was not so we played the tie there and lost 23-7. It had been a long time for players to go without passing, kicking and dropping balls but the Cup defeat was the least of our worries. When the 2009/10 season ended so did our place in the Premier Division.
Matches over the New Year festivities have been few and far between but one just over four years ago is worth recalling. On New Year’s Eve 2016 we were aiming for a win that would secure us a place in the top eight of a Premier Division that had been split for reasons only those at HQ could explain.
Our visitors were Cardiff and a battle royal ensued which we won 24-20, a close run affair that led webmaster Robert Smith to comment, “It was tense. A wandering fingernail salesman did a roaring trade on the bank but the players needed to remain calm and do what they do best. For Ebbw this meant scrummaging and there was an inevitability about the penalty try that came as Cardiff repeatedly collapsed the advancing Steelmen eight.”
The game ended a memorable year. On Sunday 15th May we had gone for the second time to Sardis Road to play Pontypridd in the Principality Premiership Play-Off Final and won handsomely 31-12. Fingernail salesman left by half-time for there was never any doubt of the result, Dan Haymond finishing the show with a dash down the touchline and a flying touchdown at the club house end.
Recall those games by studying the teams listed below, both skilfully coached by Nigel Davies, captained by the formidable and towering Damien Hudd and featuring Ronnie Kynes the Premiership Player of the Year whose try scoring resulted in an addition to rugby’s vocabulary, Catch n’Kynes.
v Pontypridd 15 May 2016
Dan Haymond; David Williams, Nathan Preece, Adam Jones, Jared Rosser; Dai Langdon, Chris Thomas; Ross Jones, Matthew Williams, Gethin Robinson; Damien Hudd (capt), Ashley Sweet; Rhys Clarke, Ronnie Kynes, Cameron Regan.
Replacements:- Joe Franchi, Ian George, Robert Sevenoaks, Josh Jacas, Luke Crocker, Tom Edwards, Iain Smerdon, Harrison Keddie.
v Cardiff 31 December 2016
Dan Haymond; Nathan Preece, Gareth Maule, Dai Langdon, Craig Duncan; Josh Lewis, Dai Jones; Ross Jones, Joe Franchi, Gethin Robinson; Jonathan Davies, Damien Hudd (capt); Rhys Clarke, Ronnie Kynes, Harrison Keddie.
Replacements:- Jonny Bowen, Ian George. Robert Sevenoaks, Max Williams, Jack Goodey, Chris Thomas, Srdan Majkic, Dawid Rubasniak.
T’WAS THE GAME BEFORE CHRISTMAS
Charles Dickens who wrote about funny people and hard times introduced us to Scrooge and ghosts of Christmas past. Since there has been no rugby to play or watch live we too have gone back in time and recalled players and games past like a Gwent Derby on the afternoon before Christmas 1960 that still haunts those who saw it.
The aim of fixture secretaries before they were made redundant by leagues was to play neighbouring teams over Christmas and the New Year. It reduced the travelling but strangely back in the days of charabancs and narrow roads we ventured far and wide at Festive time. Ebbw Vale played three games in December 1922, the first two locally against Blaenavon and Cross Keys and the third at Port Talbot to play Aberavon for the first time. It was also the first and last time we played on Christmas Day.
On Boxing Day in the Thirties we played Rugby RFC in the Midlands and Devonport Services, Taunton and Exeter in Devon and it wasn’t until the Fifties that we began Boxing Day fixtures with Abertillery, a Jones Bus ride away. When Christmas Eve was a Saturday it was business as usual and in 1960 we were home to Newport, a holiday fixture to bring joy to club treasurers with Scrooge-like tendencies.
From the 2nd of January 1960 to the 24th of December when Newport came we had played 37 games winning 28, drawing 3 and losing 6 so we fancied our chance and it looked like a happy Christmas with five minutes to go and a 3-0 lead. We were not helped by being a man short for the last fifteen minutes and were defending the clubhouse end on the bank side when Newport wing-forward Brian Cresswell scored a try to level the score and from the touchline full-back Norman Morgan who worked in the nearby Cold Mill in between playing for Newport and Wales, converted. Newport got the season’s double, their players and supporters had the Christmas present they had asked Father Christmas for while Ebbw Valians faced a Christmas less merry than usual.
When Leagues came in the WRU tried to arrange local Derbies over the Festive season but on Boxing Days 2006 and 2007 some bright spark at HQ decided we would play Llandovery. Obviously he or she had failed in geography but both games were perfect for the day after Christmas and not just because we won 18-16 and 18-13. Our supporters turned up at Llandovery in Hawaiian costumes and added colour and noise to a cold day, so cold even the Drover’s sheep wore thermals.
The last game we played was on March 7th of this year, home to RGC 1404 which we won 20-17 having earlier beaten them in North Wales 31-28. We had found our true form and were rarin’ to go when the season came to a grinding halt since when we have waited patiently for club rugby to re-start and passed some of the time recalling games and Ebbw Vale players of the Past.
We now look forward to the time when our players start creating their own history again and send sincere Christmas greetings to the Present with best wishes for a Happier, Healthier and Normal New Year.
STEELMEN SPREAD THEIR WINGS
The installation of floodlights allowed fixture secretaries to spread games throughout the winter instead of packing them into the autumn and spring months. April was very busy with Easter Bank Holiday games and end of season tours to Cornwall reaching a peak in 1972 when the team played nine games in twenty-six days and travelled thousands of miles.
It began on the 4th April with a 10-16 defeat at Pontypool Park but from then on it was victory all the way. Three days later we won 12-10 at Rodney Parade where we didn’t stay long because cases had to be packed for a tour that began next day. Twenty four hours after playing Newport the team was in the air heading for Los Angeles.
A packed programme awaited them and two days after landing they played UCLA (University of Los Angeles California) and won 10-4, not an impressive score but jet lag and hot sun didn’t help. That was on April 10th, four days later the party moved up the coast to Santa Barbara and won 54-12. Still heading north three days later they played in California’s capital Sacramento and won 22-10.
By then the team had got used to Budweiser, big breakfasts and weather as warm as the hospitality but winning was paramount. Two days later Ebbw played San Francisco a city of cable car rides and an atmosphere all its own and won 47-6, a preview of the return game in Ebbw Vale the following September which we won 84-4, our highest ever score.
The main opposition in the city were and still are the Bay Area Touring side, the BATS, who did well but were beaten 22-16. That was on April 21st, next day the team flew home, arriving on the 23rd and four days later really came down to earth drawing 7-7 at home to Abertillery.
The hectic programme had not ended, three days after the Abertillery game we were home to Newbridge and won 19-3. Then a memorable season finished and the players could rest and think back to a tour of a lifetime which we repeated eight years later.
The club has a good record in North America and were undefeated in two tours to California, one to Florida and another to Canada in 1982 a tour originally planned for the Far East. Fixtures were to be played in Bangkok and Singapore but the distance, the cost and doubt over the beer changed our minds and we went to Toronto and Ottawa instead. A wise decision and a fine tour, four games and four wins.
A year later the Steelmen flew to Italy where rugby was becoming popular. Three games were played in a week, the first against Zebre which was then an invitational select side that included Clive Burgess who was playing for Brescia in Lombardy and seven other full internationals including the Leicester and England half-backs Les Cusworth and Nick Young. Zebre won 38-10, a few days later we took on an Italian National XV who won 16-4 and the tour ended with victory over the host club Brescia 22-9.
Ten months later we played Brescia in Ebbw Vale and won 20-16 against a side with eight capped players at all levels and led by the master of backrow play Clive Burgess who scored a try in the last game he played on the ground. There was no player like Budgie and there never will be.
THE DOCTOR WHO SCORED A TRY THAT CAUSED A STIR
Among several unusual fixtures in pre-league times was one against St. Mary’s Hospital one of London’s medical schools that not only produceddoctors but rugby players some of whom were capped by England. When St. Mary’s played at Ebbw Vale on their 1956 Easter tour we wondered how so many were released from hospital duties but as Max Boyce would say perhaps they all had doctor’s papers.
We won 11-3 against a side that included an England centre Lewis Cannellwho was capped nineteen times from 1948 to 1957 and must have been good because he was selected by the Barbarians to play alongside the Prince of Centres Bleddyn Williams against the 1951/2 Springboks.
The 1956 Hospital Cup final was played at Richmond between the holders Guys and St. Mary’s whose experience of playing in Wales paid off for they won 6-5. Rugger types didn’t approve of anything unusual and were shocked by an incident that afternoon later described as “likely to be remembered by all who watched or played in the game.”
With a few minutes left Guy’s were leading 5-3 when they were penalised in their 25. A St. Mary’s player, whose name escapes me so let’s call himDoctor Who, placed the ball and as the defenders trudged back to their goal-line he shaped up for the expected kick at goal but instead tapped the ball forward, picked it up, nipped over for a try in the corner and St. Mary’s won 6-5.
It was controversial and no TMO to give a second opinion but if there had been he would have disallowed the try because the move did not comply with current laws on the taking of penalty kicks. It was also regarded as an abuse of the spirit of the game but the result stood thanks to the quick-thinking of the doctor who was talk of the wards when he went to work next day.
Another one–off fixture was unusually played on a Thursday in September 1973. The first four games of the season were against Newbridge, Cardiff, Penarth and Gloucester and then came an added attraction, the Irish Wolfhounds. They were led by scrum-half John Maloney who played 27 times for Ireland with Willie John McBride and Mike Gibson and went with the 1974 Lions who were undefeated in South Africa. Six other internationals who came with the Wolfhounds had played for Leinster against the touring Fijians a few weeks before so we were up against formidable opposition but won a great game 13-7.
In the club’s early days there were very few unusual fixtures like that and matches were mainly against clubs in the County. Players and supporters travelled to away games by bus or Great Western Railway whose station was a few yards from our ground. On Saturday October 13th 1906 we were home to Blaenavon and four hundred of their supporters came by special train. Matches were fully reported in local papers and the account of the game in the Merthyr Express eloquently described a hard Western v Eastern Valley clash which we won 3-0 through a first half try by outside-half Billy Thomas.
On April 23rd 1977 we hosted an English team but didn’t play them. ThePhyllosans, all over forty, led by our former full-back Clive Best came to watch his old club play Llanelli, an important game with the Welsh Championship yet to be decided. We won 7-3 and our visitors from Essexenjoyed the rugby and the occasion after a hard season playing formidable opponents like Chelmsford Undertakers and Hertford Termites.
This reminder of odd fixtures and unusual happenings was of a time when clubs decided who they would play, where and when. In 1968 Mary Hopkins sang “Those were the days my friend, we thought they’d never end” and we thought seasons of 45-50 games against teams from far and wide would go on for ever. But they didn’t and now they are but memories of the way we were.