There are two stand out achievements in the club's history. In 1989/90 they reached the FA Trophy final as a Northern Premier League Division One side. Along the way Blues beat Conference sides Telford United, Darlington and Stafford Rangers before losing 3-0 to Barrow in the final at Wembley Stadium.

Then in 1996/97 the club reached the pinnacle of non-league football, the Conference after winning the Northern Premier League Division title. This remains the last silverware won by the club.

Northern Premier League: Premier Division Champions 1996/97, Runners-Up 1993/94

Northern Premier League: Division One Champions 1989/90

Northern Premier League: Division One South Runners-up 2014/15

Northern Premier League: President's Cup Runners-Up 1993/94, 2003/04

Southern League: League Cup Runners-Up 1994/95

FA Trophy: Finalists 1989/90

FA Cup: 2nd Round Proper 1990/91, 1st Round Proper 1993/94

Staffordshire Senior Cup: Winners 1995/96, Runners-Up 1954/55, 1979/80, 1981/82, 1984/85, 1998/99, 2004/05, 2014/15

North West Counties League: League Cup Winners 1984/85

Cheshire County League: Champions 1974/75

Manchester League: Champions 1951/52, 1971/72, 1972/73

Manchester League: League Cup Runners-Up 1972/73

Staffordshire County League Champions: 1949/50, 1950/51